Advice
The Sandwich Squeeze: Why Middle Managers Are Having Mental Breakdowns (And How to Stop It)
Middle management isn't glamorous. Never has been.
You're not the CEO getting photographed for the industry magazines or the graduate trainee everyone wants to mentor. You're the person stuck between a demanding executive team who treats you like a mind reader and a team of direct reports who think you're personally responsible for every policy change that comes down from corporate. Welcome to the psychological pressure cooker that is middle management in 2025.
After seventeen years in various management roles across Melbourne and Sydney - from supervising warehouse teams to running entire departments - I've watched brilliant professionals crack under pressures that nobody talks about in leadership courses. The statistics are bloody alarming: 67% of middle managers report feeling "emotionally exhausted" at work, according to recent workplace wellness surveys. That's not just tired after a long day. That's burnt-out, can't-sleep-properly, snapping-at-your-family exhausted.
Here's what they don't tell you in those shiny management training programmes.
The Invisible Weight
Middle managers carry invisible weight. You're accountable for everything your team does wrong, but rarely get credit when things go right. Sound familiar? When your team hits targets, it's because "the strategy was solid." When they miss targets, it's because your leadership was lacking.
I remember my first middle management role at a logistics company in Brisbane. My boss would regularly throw me under the bus in executive meetings, then expect me to motivate a team who'd heard through the grapevine that I was "struggling with the role." The psychological toll was immense. You start questioning your own competence, even when the problem is systemic.
The stress reduction training approaches I've seen actually work focus on recognising these patterns early. Because once you're in the spiral, it's much harder to climb out.
The Decision-Making Paralysis
Middle managers make approximately 35,000 decisions per day. Okay, I made that number up, but it feels accurate, doesn't it? You're constantly triaging: which fire to put out first, which complaint deserves immediate attention, which team member needs coaching versus which one needs a performance improvement plan.
The paralysis comes when you realise every decision has consequences you can't fully predict. Approve overtime for one person, and three others will want the same treatment. Implement a new process, and someone will inevitably hate it. The pressure to make the "right" decision every time is psychologically crushing.
What's worse? You rarely have all the information you need to make good decisions. Upper management filters information down to you selectively. Your team filters information up to you selectively. You're making calls with incomplete data, knowing you'll be held responsible for the outcomes.
The Empathy Overload
This is the one that nearly broke me in 2019. As a middle manager, you become the emotional dumping ground for your entire team. Sarah's going through a divorce and can't concentrate. James is dealing with his father's terminal illness. Michelle is struggling with anxiety and needs flexible working arrangements.
You want to support them - you're not a monster. But you've also got KPIs to hit and a boss breathing down your neck about productivity. The emotional labour of being everyone's problem solver while maintaining team performance is exhausting. Some weeks I felt more like a counsellor than a manager.
The best emotional intelligence training programmes teach you how to be supportive without becoming overwhelmed. Setting boundaries isn't selfish - it's essential for sustainability.
The Communication Minefield
Middle managers are professional translators. You take corporate speak from the top and translate it into practical instructions for your team. You take ground-level concerns from your team and translate them into business language for the executives.
Lost in translation? Your sanity.
I once spent three hours in meetings trying to explain why our "streamlined efficiency initiative" (translation: we're cutting staff) was actually going to improve "work-life balance and job satisfaction" (translation: the remaining people will work harder). The cognitive dissonance of having to sell policies you disagree with while maintaining credibility with your team is mentally exhausting.
You become fluent in corporate bullshit out of necessity, but part of you dies each time you hear yourself saying "synergistic opportunities" instead of "we need to work together."
The Promotion Trap
Here's the thing about middle management: it often feels like a career cul-de-sac. You're too senior to go back to individual contributor roles, but not senior enough to influence real strategic decisions. You're stuck in the middle, watching junior staff get promoted past you to executive roles while you're managing the day-to-day operations that keep the business running.
The psychological impact of feeling professionally trapped is significant. You start questioning whether the extra responsibility is worth the marginal salary increase. You wonder if you should have stayed in your previous role where you could leave work at work.
I see this particularly in Melbourne's professional services sector, where middle managers often plateau for 5-7 years while the organisation restructures around them.
The Impostor Syndrome Amplifier
Middle management amplifies impostor syndrome like nothing else. You're responsible for developing others while often feeling underdeveloped yourself. You're expected to have answers you don't have, make decisions you're not qualified for, and lead people who might be more capable than you are.
The constant self-doubt is corrosive. Am I good enough? Do I deserve this role? Can I handle the next challenge? The psychological pressure builds because you can't show vulnerability to your team (they need to trust your leadership) or your boss (they need to believe you can handle more responsibility).
The Solutions Nobody Wants to Implement
Most organisations know their middle managers are struggling. The solutions aren't complicated, but they require investment and cultural change that makes executives uncomfortable.
Proper Management Training: Not a two-day course on "leadership principles," but ongoing development in practical skills like difficult conversations, performance management, and psychological resilience. Companies like Atlassian have recognised that middle management is a specialised skill set requiring specialised training.
Clear Authority Boundaries: Middle managers need clear guidelines about what decisions they can make independently. Nothing breeds anxiety faster than unclear authority. Can I approve this expense? Can I hire this person? Can I change this process? If you don't know, you'll either be paralysed or overreach.
Regular Check-Ins: Middle managers need managers too. Not just performance reviews, but genuine coaching and support. The best senior leaders I've worked with understood that developing middle managers was crucial for organisational success.
Realistic Expectations: Stop expecting middle managers to be mind readers, miracle workers, and emotional support systems simultaneously. The role has limits, and acknowledging those limits is healthier than pretending they don't exist.
The Reality Check
Middle management will always involve psychological pressure. The role exists because someone needs to bridge the gap between strategy and execution, between corporate goals and human reality. But the pressure doesn't have to be crushing.
The strongest middle managers I know have learned to compartmentalise, delegate effectively, and protect their mental health proactively. They've accepted that they can't solve every problem or please every person. They've developed thick skin for criticism and realistic expectations for outcomes.
Most importantly, they've recognised that middle management is a legitimate career choice, not a stepping stone to something better. The role serves a crucial function in organisations, and doing it well requires skill, resilience, and psychological strength.
If you're a middle manager reading this, know that the pressure you feel is real and valid. You're not imagining it, and you're not weak for struggling with it. The role is genuinely challenging, and acknowledging that challenge is the first step to managing it effectively.
The sandwich squeeze doesn't have to squash you. But it requires conscious effort to maintain your psychological wellbeing while meeting the demands of the role. And that's perfectly acceptable.
Our Favourite Blogs: